Skip to main content

Cincinnati Financial Corporation (CINF) Stock

Cincinnati Financial Corporation Stock Details, Movements and Public Alerts

Cincinnati Financial Corporation (CINF): The 65-Year Dividend Aristocrat Weathering California Wildfires

When Stephen Spray became CEO of Cincinnati Financial in May 2024, he inherited a company with one of insurance's most impressive track records: 65 consecutive years of rising dividends. The Cincinnati Insurance Company serves business, home, and auto customers through thousands of independent agents across the U.S., anchored by a strategy Spray describes as "agent-centered" rather than direct-to-consumer. That approach delivered a decade of profitable growth until California wildfires and multi-state spring storms hammered Q1 2025 results with a $90 million net loss. But the swift Q2 recovery to $685 million in net income, combined with a 7% dividend increase to $0.87 quarterly, demonstrates why CINF remains a core holding for income-focused investors seeking insurance exposure with aristocratic dividend credentials.

52-Week Range

$166.90 - $121.60

-7.51% from high · +26.94% from low

Avg Daily Volume

742,429

Latest volume

Fundamentals

Valuation Metrics

P/E Ratio (TTM)

13.56

Below market average

Forward P/E

18.45

Earnings expected to decline

PEG Ratio

-158.72

Potentially undervalued

Price to Book

1.72

EPS (TTM)

$11.53

Price to Sales

2.10

Beta

0.73

Less volatile than market

How is CINF valued relative to its earnings and growth?
Cincinnati Financial Corporation trades at a P/E ratio of 13.56, which is below the market average of approximately 20. This lower valuation could indicate the market has modest growth expectations, or it might represent an undervalued opportunity if the fundamentals are strong. Looking ahead, the forward P/E of 18.45 is higher than the current P/E, indicating analysts expect earnings to decline over the next year. The PEG ratio of -158.72 suggests the stock may be undervalued relative to its growth rate.
What is CINF's risk profile compared to the market?
With a beta of 0.73, Cincinnati Financial Corporation is less volatile than the overall market. This means when the market moves up or down by 10%, this stock typically moves less than 10% in the same direction. Lower beta stocks are often preferred by conservative investors seeking stability. The price-to-book ratio of 1.72 shows investors value the company above its book value, which often reflects intangible assets or growth prospects.

Performance & Growth

Profit Margin

15.60%

Operating Margin

26.80%

EBITDA

$2.45B

Return on Equity

13.40%

Return on Assets

3.90%

Revenue Growth (YoY)

27.70%

Earnings Growth (YoY)

119.20%

How profitable and efficient is CINF's business model?
Cincinnati Financial Corporation achieves a profit margin of 15.60%, meaning it retains $15.60 from every $100 in revenue after all expenses. This is an impressive margin, indicating strong pricing power and efficient cost management that allows the company to generate substantial profits. The operating margin of 26.80% reveals how efficiently the company runs its core business operations before interest and taxes. With ROE at 13.40% and ROA at 3.90%, the company achieves moderate returns on invested capital.
What are CINF's recent growth trends?
Cincinnati Financial Corporation's revenue grew by 27.70% year-over-year, representing robust expansion that significantly outpaces typical market growth rates. This strong top-line performance suggests the company is successfully capturing market share or benefiting from favorable industry trends. Earnings increased by 119.20% year-over-year, outpacing revenue growth through improved margins. These growth metrics should be evaluated against INSURANCE - PROPERTY & CASUALTY industry averages for proper context.

Dividend Information

Dividend Per Share

$3.36

Dividend Yield

2.14%

Ex-Dividend Date

Sep 22, 2025

Dividend Date

Oct 15, 2025

What dividend income can investors expect from CINF?
Cincinnati Financial Corporation offers a dividend yield of 2.14%, paying $3.36 per share annually. This above-average yield of 2-4% provides meaningful income while still allowing the company to reinvest for growth. It compares favorably to the S&P 500 average and offers competitive returns versus bonds in the current rate environment. To receive the next dividend, shares must be purchased before the ex-dividend date of Sep 22, 2025.
How reliable is CINF's dividend for long-term investors?
The dividend sustainability can be assessed through the payout ratio - Cincinnati Financial Corporation pays $3.36 per share in dividends against earnings of $11.53 per share, resulting in a payout ratio of 29.14%. This conservative payout below 30% indicates excellent dividend safety with substantial room for future increases. The company retains most earnings for growth while still rewarding shareholders. The next dividend payment is scheduled for Oct 15, 2025.

Company Size & Market

Market Cap

$24.5B

Revenue (TTM)

$11.67B

Revenue/Share (TTM)

$74.68

Shares Outstanding

156.38M

Book Value/Share

$91.50

Asset Type

Common Stock

What is CINF's market capitalization and position?
Cincinnati Financial Corporation has a market capitalization of $24.5B, classifying it as a large-cap stock ($10B-$200B). Large-caps are typically industry leaders with established business models, offering a balance of stability and growth potential. They often provide dividend income and are core holdings in institutional portfolios. With 156.38M shares outstanding, the company's ownership is relatively concentrated. As a participant in the INSURANCE - PROPERTY & CASUALTY industry, it competes with other firms in this sector.
How does CINF's price compare to its book value?
Cincinnati Financial Corporation's book value per share is $91.50, while the current stock price is $154.36, resulting in a price-to-book (P/B) ratio of 1.69. This reasonable premium to book value suggests the market values the company's earnings power and intangible assets appropriately. Most profitable companies trade between 1-3x book value. As a common stock, this represents equity ownership with voting rights.

Analyst Ratings

Analyst Target Price

$163.33

5.81% upside potential

Analyst Recommendations

Strong Buy

1

Buy

3

Hold

4

Sell

0

Strong Sell

0

How reliable are analyst predictions for CINF?
8 analysts cover CINF with 50% recommending buy/strong buy ratings. Analyst predictions have mixed reliability - studies show consensus rarely beats market returns consistently. The mixed views reflect uncertainty about the outlook. The consensus target of $163.33 implies 5.8% upside, but targets are often adjusted to follow price moves rather than predict them.
What is the Wall Street consensus on CINF?
Current analyst recommendations:1 Strong Buy, 3 Buy, 4 Hold, 00The neutral stance suggests uncertainty or fair valuation at current levels.Remember that analyst opinions often lag price movements and can be influenced by investment banking relationships.

Fundamentals last updated: Oct 1, 2025, 06:07 AM

Active Alerts

No active alerts for this stock.

Be the first to set up an alert for CINF and get notified when the price changes.

Cincinnati Financial Corporation (CINF) Stock Analysis 2025: Complete Investment Guide

The Insurance Aristocrat That Weathered Wildfire Season

Most insurance companies tout financial strength and customer service. Cincinnati Financial Corporation has something rarer: 65 consecutive years of dividend increases, a track record achieved by fewer than 70 U.S. public companies across all sectors. When Stephen Spray took the CEO role in May 2024, he committed to maintaining that legacy while navigating an insurance market challenged by climate-driven catastrophes. The California wildfires that torched Q1 2025 earnings tested that commitment immediately, delivering a $90 million quarterly loss. Spray's response—maintaining the dividend increase schedule while leveraging $5 billion in parent company cash to absorb losses—demonstrated the capital allocation discipline that sustains dividend aristocrat status through underwriting cycles.

Business Model & Competitive Moat

Cincinnati Financial generates revenue by underwriting property and casualty insurance for businesses and individuals, plus life insurance and fixed annuities through subsidiary Cincinnati Life Insurance Company. What differentiates CINF from competitors like Progressive or Geico is the distribution model: Cincinnati exclusively partners with independent insurance agents rather than direct-to-consumer channels or captive agents.

This agent-centered approach creates sticky relationships—agents value Cincinnati's underwriting flexibility, claims responsiveness, and profit-sharing arrangements that reward profitable business. The model produces higher acquisition costs than direct writers, but generates superior retention and allows premium pricing that direct competitors cannot match. With a decade of profitable growth despite adding products, capabilities, and geographies, the agent strategy has proven durable even as digital-first insurers disrupt the industry.

Financial Performance

  • •Q1 2025: Net loss of $90 million (-$0.57/share) vs. $755M profit ($4.78/share) in Q1 2024
  • •Q1 Drivers: California wildfire losses and spring storms across 21 states materially impacted earnings
  • •Q2 2025 Recovery: Net income $685 million ($4.34/share) vs. $312M in Q2 2024 (+120% YoY)
  • •Balance Sheet: $5 billion in parent company cash and marketable securities
  • •Dividend: $3.48 annual ($0.87 quarterly), 2.27% yield, 7.69% one-year growth
  • •Payout Ratio: 29.14%, providing substantial reinvestment capacity

The Q1-to-Q2 swing from $90 million loss to $685 million profit illustrates both catastrophe vulnerability and recovery capability. The low payout ratio ensures dividend safety even during loss years.

Growth Catalysts

  • •Leadership Structure: 2025 reorganization with Sean Givler (commercial/life) and Will Van Den Heuvel (personal/specialty) streamlines operations
  • •Geographic Expansion: Continued expansion into new states while deepening existing market penetration
  • •Product Diversification: Added capabilities in management liability, surety, and specialty lines beyond core P&C
  • •Agent Network Growth: Expanding partnerships with independent agents in profitable markets
  • •Pricing Power: Hardening insurance market allows premium increases without volume loss
  • •Investment Portfolio: Rising interest rates benefit fixed income returns on float

Risks & Challenges

  • •Catastrophe Exposure: Climate change driving increased frequency and severity of wildfires, hurricanes, storms
  • •California Risk: Q1 2025 wildfires demonstrated concentrated geographic exposure
  • •Distribution Cost: Agent-centered model carries higher expense ratio than direct writers
  • •Digital Disruption: Progressive, Lemonade, Root disrupting with AI-driven underwriting and lower costs
  • •Reinsurance Costs: Rising reinsurance premiums compress margins on catastrophe coverage
  • •Investment Risk: Equity portfolio volatility can swing quarterly results significantly
  • •Inflation Impact: Higher replacement costs and medical expenses pressure loss ratios

Competitive Landscape

In property and casualty insurance, Cincinnati competes with diversified carriers like Travelers, Chubb, and Hartford in commercial lines, and State Farm, Allstate, and Progressive in personal lines. Cincinnati's independent agent distribution differentiates it from direct writers (Progressive, Geico) and captive agent models (State Farm, Allstate), but limits market share in price-sensitive consumer segments.

The competitive advantage lies in agent loyalty and underwriting discipline rather than scale or technology. While competitors invest billions in AI underwriting and direct digital channels, Cincinnati bets that agent relationships and selective underwriting will sustain profitability. This positioning works in stable markets but faces challenges when direct writers use technology to undercut pricing or when catastrophe losses spike unexpectedly.

Who Is This Stock Suitable For?

Perfect For

  • ✓Dividend growth investors seeking 65-year track record of increases
  • ✓Income-focused portfolios requiring insurance sector exposure
  • ✓Conservative investors prioritizing financial strength over growth
  • ✓Long-term holders (10+ years) comfortable with underwriting volatility
  • ✓Those seeking lower volatility than direct P&C competitors

Less Suitable For

  • ✗Growth investors seeking capital appreciation over income
  • ✗Traders focused on short-term momentum (insurance cycles are multi-year)
  • ✗ESG investors concerned about climate risk exposure
  • ✗Those requiring high current yield (2.27% below many insurers)

Investment Thesis

Cincinnati Financial offers a classic dividend aristocrat profile: steady dividend growth, conservative management, and resilience through cycles. The bull case rests on Stephen Spray successfully executing the agent-centered strategy through hardening insurance markets, using pricing power to offset catastrophe losses while sustaining dividend increases. With a 29% payout ratio and $5 billion in cash, Cincinnati has ample room to absorb occasional loss quarters without compromising the 65-year dividend streak. Geographic and product expansion, combined with organizational improvements under the 2025 leadership structure, provide moderate growth while preserving underwriting discipline.

The bear case questions whether climate change has fundamentally altered catastrophe economics, making traditional underwriting models obsolete. If California wildfires, hurricanes, and severe storms become annual rather than periodic events, even well-capitalized insurers face margin compression that threatens dividend sustainability. The agent distribution model, while sticky, carries higher costs that technology-driven competitors are exploiting. For dividend investors with multi-decade horizons, CINF's 65-year track record and conservative balance sheet justify core allocation. The 2.27% yield is modest, but 7.69% annual growth compounds attractively. Position CINF as a defensive insurance holding that prioritizes income reliability over capital appreciation.

Conclusion

Buy for dividend growth investors seeking insurance exposure with aristocrat credentials. The 2.27% yield is modest, but 7.69% dividend growth and 65-year track record provide income reliability. Suitable for core long-term holdings with 5-10 year minimum horizon. Size position appropriately for 10-20% quarterly volatility during catastrophe years.
Bull Case
$170-180 (11-18% upside on continued dividend growth and margin expansion)
Base Case
$155-165 (1-8% upside, matching analyst consensus of $159)
Bear Case
$130-140 (10-15% downside if catastrophe frequency undermines profitability)

Stay Ahead of the Market with Cincinnati Financial Corporation Alerts

Set up price alerts for Cincinnati Financial Corporation and get notified instantly when the price hits your target. Never miss an important price movement again.